April 22, 2006
Dear Mr. Lippmann,
I have recently joined the cmkp list
and have been reading your contributions with great interest. I would like
to share with you an article I wrote for the op-ed page of DAWN, Karachi.
This was published on December 31, 2005, as a tribute to the Cuban Medical
Mission and as a comment on the ineptitude and lack of political will on the
part of our government. Please feel free to circulate it. Unfortunately I
cannot send it as an attachment due to a bug which has disabled that
facility for me. However, I am pasting it in this mail and you could
forward it to your contact at Cubanews.
Additionally, would it be possible for you to
forward me any contact in Cuba with whom I can discuss the possibility of a
film which I would like to shoot in Cuba on the doctors and nurses who
served in the earthquake zone in Pakistan? I want to explore the ideologies
and the depth of commitment which enabled these heroic people to serve in
the conditions which prevailed at the time. I also want to look at Cuba as
a beacon in the part of the world which has stifled all hope for equitable
distribution of resources and opportunity. I am a film maker with an
academic background in Political Economy and am very keen to be involved in
documenting what I see as a major progressive movement taking place in Latin
America today. I would be very grateful for any contacts that you may have.
Lastly, my second novel (the first: The
Scent of Wet Earth in August (Penguin 2002) was number 5 on the New
York Times International Best Seller list) is based on the American presence
in Afghanistan since October 2001 and is titled: No Space for
Further Burials. This book shall be published by the end of this
year and I am looking for interest in translations, particularly into
Spanish for Latin America. Please send me any leads you may have.
With profound regards,
Feryal Ali
Gauhar
From: Feryal Ali-Gauhar
feryalkimail@yahoo.com
Sent: Saturday, April 22, 2006 10:54 PM
To: walterlx@earthlink.net
Subject: Greetings from Lahore
In the shadow of the dying year
By Feryal Ali Gauhar
On our last evening on this
land we chop our days
From our young trees, count the ribs we'll take with us
And the ribs we'll leave
behind "On the last evening
We bid nothing farewell, nor
find the time to end"
Agha Shahid Ali
"Rooms are never finished"
It is quiet here; nothing stirs amidst the ruin
and the despair except for the longing of the heart.
Ninety days on and the stillness runs through this valley like a river.
In the evening the sky is a dark bowl, the earth a fractured promise.
Women gather around open fireplaces, stirring the evening's meal with
hands which have dug the ground, searching for a life torn at the edges,
ripped apart like a slaughtered animal's skin. Children's
voices filter through the air; there is the soft balm of laughter, hope
amidst so much desolation.
This is Maira, situated at 3500 feet above sea
level. People from the upper reaches of the
At the edge of the camp a few open fires light
up the dark night. Several women huddle around the dying
embers. In their arms they carry sick children,
plaintive cries piercing the still night. They are
talking to the doctors who take the children in their arms and rock them
gently, soothing the pain, easing the heartache. There
is a medley of languages here, a symphony of sounds which speaks so many
messages at once. This is the field hospital set up by
the medical mission from
The first Cuban medical team was in
Cuban President Fidel Castro said recently in a
televised interview that unlike other countries which sent "equipment,
a number of helicopters and a few million dollars",
Today, more than a thousand Cuban medical
personnel, 789 of them trained doctors, are working in remote mountain
villages in
What is it which makes this overseas medical
mission steadfast in the face of harsh climactic and geographical
conditions? What makes people from the other side of the
world give up their families, the comfort of their homes, the certainty of
their cultures, to come and work in unfamiliar and sometimes frightening
circumstances? Is there something in Fidel Castro's
reference to the genuine revolution which has inculcated undying human
values? Is there something we, in this blessed, blighted
land, need to consider before we begin another year, faltering on a course
carved out by simplistic ideology, framed in the comfortable if confining
box of myopia? Is there something missing in the vacuous
rhetoric of our leadership which insists on its own innate supremacy and the
inherent stupidity of those who are led? Can we, for
even a fleeting moment, believe that a leadership which has bolstered itself
as the right arm of the most brutal regime in the world, that this
leadership will have the foresight and the sensitivity to lead entire
nations away from what it considers is mass suicide?
In Maira, the current pre-occupation of this
leadership with the supposed lemming-like proclivity of the people of Sindh
seems to be out of place with the magnitude of the disaster before us.
The fact that 28,000 acres of farming land in the NWFP and 15,000
acres of farming land in Kashmir have been devastated, that thousands have
lost their lives, that millions have lost their livelihoods and their homes,
that an entire generation of youth has been decimated, should prod this
leadership into considering for a moment the dangerous course it has set its
sights upon. To the ordinary, the manner in which the
concerns of the citizens of this country are being addressed is
inappropriate and unacceptable. It is certainly not
enough to rest on the faded and false laurels of having generated "funding"
for the rebuilding of nine districts devastated by a lack of respect for the
fragility of the ecosystem and the lack of concern for the holistic
well-being of communities. It is not enough to place a
timorous hand on the head of an orphaned child, mouthing platitudes about
turning disaster into opportunity. For the thousands of
families who have not even been able to bury their dead, there is no
opportunity in this disaster. The opportunity which
leadership lost is precisely the cause for the scale of the devastation
being witnessed today not only in our northern areas, but certainly in the
rapidly deteriorating
What is it that allows for the thickened
membrane of myopia to creep over one's sight, obscuring one's vision,
obfuscating real issues and trivializing the lives of those one leads?
What is that unholy source of inebriation which drives one to begin
believing in rhetoric created by spin-doctors who have been in the pay of
others but who make us feel as if we were the only Kings to whom they pay
obeisance? Why is it that the obvious truth is
constantly dismissed as being a product of the dubious domain of
thoughtfulness and genuine concern? Why are the dynamics
of unbridled population growth and the inequitable distribution of resources
not considered as endemic to any understanding of the growing dissonance
between consensus and conflict? Why are the linkages
between state neglect, political exclusivism, growing disparity and mounting
discontent not clear to a junta which has fattened itself on the sale and
allotment of real estate beyond the realm of the imagination?
Is this our failing, to not challenge the
veracity of the claims being made by this designer-suited dispensation which
functions almost entirely on the giving and taking of orders, and does not
condone the questioning of the validity, purpose and efficacy of those
orders? Is it our failing, too, to bask passively in the
pale winter sunlight while conditions for a civil war ripen in at least half
of our country? Shall we continue to wallow in the
quagmire of decadence while young children arch their backs in the crippling
vice of tetanus fever, while others in the impoverished Union Council of
Bugra Memon peer over the horizon of the encroaching ocean, seeking some
purpose amidst the ruins of what was once arable land and a delta rich with
alluvial deposits and dreams of rich marine harvests?
How long shall we stand by, watching this parade of tyrants masquerading as
benevolent, benign Masters of All they Survey? How long
before the malignancy which is inherent in the destruction of civil society
consciousness becomes apparent to us? How long before
the river of silence which flows through the
It is evening now. Tomorrow
I shall return to my other life, taking with me fragments of other lives.
As night begins to envelope this valley in its dark embrace, I hear
silence falling all around us like a shroud. Only the
sound of the river soothes the turmoil inside, only the sad knowledge that
we are now incapable of irony, that this land will now host atoms of dust.
Here,
on our last evening, we look closely at the mountains besieging the clouds,
a conquest, a counter-conquest.